The Law of knowing God’s Vicegerent

The law of knowing God’s vicegerent (Arabic- Khalifa Allah) or the divine appointment has been the consistent and established way which is mentioned in all the Abrahamic religions. This is even documented in the Sumerian clay tablets.  

The law consists of three elements:

  1. The Will/ Text about Divine Appointment
  2. Divine Knowledge
  3. The Banner- Supremacy of God

1. The Will/ Text about Divine Appointment

It is the text that personifies the vicegerent of God, and includes the following:

A) Pronouncement by God

E.g. The pronouncement of Adam to the angels by God.

Remember’ when your Lord said to the angels, “I am going to place a Vicegerent (Khalifa) on earth.” They asked God, “Will You place in it someone who will spread corruption there and shed blood while we glorify Your praises and proclaim Your holiness?” God responded, “I know what you do not know.” (Quran 2:30)

Also, similar to that are the frequent or number of visions that provide reassurance that the people who have seen them have not conspired to lie. It is to be noted that the vision must match the personifying text.

B) Pronouncement by the Vicegerent of God

There are two ways the pronouncement can be relayed by the Vicegerent of God.

B.1) Direct Pronouncement– It is the pronouncement by the vicegerent of God of his direct successor e.g. Pronouncement by David of Solomon, Moses of Joshua, and the Messenger of God PBUHAP of Ali, upon them all peace.

Q- Has the 12th Imam- Muhammad ibn Hasan pronounced appointment of his successor- the first Mahdi, Ahmed Al-Hasan?
The 12th Imam, Muhammad ibn Hasan pbuh is raised and absent. The means of communication with those who believe in him are the revelation, the visions and meeting him. And through them, he has testified to a number of people that cannot conspire to lie that Ahmed al-Hasan is his son and successor from the progeny of Muhammad PBUT.

B.2) Indirect Pronouncement– It is the statement from the vicegerent of God mentioning the one who comes after him even if after a period of time. E.g. the statement of Isaiah about Jesus, Jesus about Messenger of God Muhammad, and Prophet Muhammad (p) about the Imams from the family of Muhammad pbut.

In order for such a statement to be personifying, there must be a divine guarantee that it is protected from being claimed by the false ones. So that whoever claims such personifying text becomes its rightful owner. It is to be noted that fake claimants can still claim divine position in general, e.g. the claim of being a Prophet, a Mahdi etc., however claiming of the divine text that personifies the vicegerent of God is protected from being claimed falsely until its rightful owner—the mentioned vicegerent of God—claims it and its purpose is fulfilled.

What is the divine text that mentions Ahmed Al-Hasan?

It is the Will of Prophet Muhammad that the Messenger of God dictated during the night of his death. Prophet Muhammad (p) has stated in it that there will be 12 Imams after him and after them 12 Mahdis. Ahmed is mentioned as the successor of 12th Imam and the first believer in him. God Almighty has described the Will of Messenger of God as a book preventing from misguidance for whoever holds on to it, through the words of His Prophet (p). Thus the Knowledgeable, the Capable, the Wise, the Absolute One must protect the text, which He described to be a prevention from misguidance for whoever held on to it. He must protect it from being claimed by the people of falsehood until its rightful owner claims it and its purpose is fulfilled. The mere claim of Ahmed Al-Hasan of the Will of Prophet Muhammad (p) demonstrates that he is the promised First Mahdi mentioned in it and a vicegerent of God.

2. Divine Knowledge

Divine knowledge is the weapon of the Prophets and the Vicegerents. This is known from their speech, solutions for problems, and the existing matters. It must be that people free themselves from their desires and ego in order to ascertain their knowledge.

It was the proof of God upon the Angels about the Vicegerency of Adam pbuh: “And He taught Adam the names – all of them. Then He showed them to the angels and said, “Inform Me of the names of these, if you are truthful.”” (Quran 2:31)

3. The Banner- Supremacy of God

It is the Banner of supremacy of God or call towards God’s sovereignty. The Almighty demanded this to be for His first Vicegerent Adam (p):
“And when I have proportioned him and breathed into him of my spirit, then fall down to him in prostration.” (Quran 15:29). Meaning, obey and do what he commands you for he is my Vicegerent.

The Vicegerent of God calls towards supremacy of God- the belief system that the Almighty is pleased with. The belief that sovereignty belongs to God and whoever God appoints. In Islam, this is the belief of the progeny of Muhammad PBUT.

God is the Absolute Sovereign. The owner of the earth and all that exists.

It is mentioned in the Holy Quran: ‘Say, “O God, Owner of Sovereignty, You give sovereignty to whom You will and You take sovereignty away from whom You will. You honor whom You will and You humble whom You will. In Your hand is [all] good. Indeed, You are over all things competent.” Surah 3:26

Therefore, in order for sovereignty to be transferred to someone else, the appointment has to come from the Almighty. Any other appointment is simply usurping God’s governance. In this regard, the Almighty has said, “I am about to make a Vicegerent (Khalifa) on the earth” Surah 2:30. Following this verse, no one is entitled to appoint or elect a ruler unless the appointment is by God. Indeed, this divine sovereignty is granted by God to whomever He wills.

Moreover, it is not necessary that the king appointed by God truly reigns, for he might be subdued and alienated as it has always been from the onset of humanity. Abraham (p) did not rule, Nimrod did. Moses (p) did not rule either, Pharaoh did. Jesus (p) didn’t rule but Caesar did. God says in the Holy Quran, “Or do they envy men for what God has given them out of His bounty? If that is so, surely, We gave the Book and Wisdom to the children of Abraham also and We also gave them a great kingdom” (An-Nisa:54)

The story of Talut

“Hast thou not heard of the chiefs of the children of Israel after Moses, when they said to a Prophet of theirs, ‘Appoint for us a king that we may fight in the cause of God?” Al- Baqara:246

This faithful and honest community of the people of Israel believes in the supremacy of God. Indeed, they did not appoint anyone. Instead, they asked God to appoint a king for them. That is the greatest evidence that the law of God, in all divine religions, acknowledges that the ruler is appointed by God and not by the people through elections.

The people do not require more than these three mechanisms in order to know the Vicegerent of God. These will not gather in any person except in the Vicegerent of God.

Rational Evidence

God Almighty is Absolute Wise and He never goes against Wisdom, thus, He must appoint the most knowledgeable one and command [people] to follow him. If a man owns a ship or a factory or any place where there are people working, is not he supposed to appoint a captain for the ship or a manager for the factory or a commander for those people, if he did not do so, and the ship sank or the factory was destroyed or any damage occurred, then would not that be an act of foolishness and lack of wisdom?

If he appointed someone but not the most knowledgeable or capable one for the position, and then there was shortage in the productivity of the factory or anything urgent occurred which caused the sinking of the ship because of his ignorance about the law of how to run a factory or how to handle an emergency, then would not that be an act of foolishness and lack of wisdom? Is not it necessary and wise to choose the most knowledgeable or to provide the chosen one with knowledge needed in order that he can be the most efficient and capable one to command the ship and get it to the shore safely and to achieve the best results for the factory?

Finally, if we assume that this person appointed someone for the ship or for the factory and that appointed person was the most knowledgeable and capable for such position, but the owner did not command those workers to obey the appointed one, and everyone acted upon his own desires, since they were not commanded to obey that leader, and then a damage was done because that leader did not command people, would not that be foolishness and lack of wisdom?! And what is the point of appointing the most knowledgeable and capable one if at the end people were not ordered to obey him?! It doesn’t seem any sane person would say something else apart from the following: “A leader must be appointed and he must possess or be provided with all the knowledge he needs and people must be commanded to obey him“

Evidence from Hadiths

Sunni Muslims

a. Al Bukhari vol. 8/ page121: Abi Saied Alkhudri quoted Prophet Muhammad (s): “ God never sent a prophet or nominated a successor(Caliph) unless he had two instincts, one exhorts him to do goodness and other encourages him to do wickedness. The infallible is the one God retains as so”

So here its mentioned that the appointment of not only Prophets but even Successors (Caliphs) is done by Allah SWT alone, there is no change before and after Prophet Muhammad(p) except the difference is only in Prophecy.

Everything else remains the same, for they are the ones who guard the religion and the Shariah. And by them Allah(swt) has perfected Islam and so there is no place for opinions and assumptions in the religion.

b. AlBukhary by Furat alQazaz heard from Abu Hazim from Abu Huraira from Prophet Muhammad (s) said:

 “The tribes of Israel were led by the Prophets, every time a Prophet deceased he was followed by another Prophet, and there will be no Prophets after me, but there will be Khulafaa (successors) and they will be many.” The companions then asked, “What do you order us?” To which the Prophet PBUH replied “Fulfil your pledge of allegiance to them one after another, and give them their rights, and truly Allah will ask them about their responsibilities”

Al Bukhari vol. 4, page 144

AlNawai’s explanation of this hadith in Muslim’s book part 12 page 231, he says this statement by Prophet Muhammad PBUH: “The tribes of Israel were led by the Prophets, each Prophet followed by another”: Means they lead as do the “Emirs” and ” The Commanders with the subordinates and politics” handling things towards the best.

Also, as mentioned in the hadith, the matter of leadership and Caliphate continues even after Prophet Muhammad (s).

So just as “Succession(Caliphate)” is not a new thing after Prophet Muhammad(p), the “Imamat” is also not a new concept after Prophet Muhammad(p), it existed before and continues after Prophet Muhammad(p).

Allah SWT says in the Holy Quran:

32:24 And We made from among them leaders guiding by Our command when they were patient and [when] they were certain of Our signs.

Transliteration: WajaAAalna minhum a-immatan yahdoonabi-amrina lamma sabaroo wakanoo bi-ayatinayooqinoon

Shia Muslims

From Jaaber Al Jufi from Abi Jaafer pbuh he said: “Whatever had caused you confusion, it shouldn’t cause you confusion over the promise of the Prophet of Allah pbuhap, his banner, and weapon and beware from the deviant people from the family of Muhammad, for the family of Muhammad and Ali is a banner and the rest are banners, stay in your place and don’t ever follow a man until a man from the son of Hussein will come with the will of the Prophet of Allah, his banner and weapon” Bihar Al Anwar v.52 p.224

Text: Ali son of Hussein pbuh said: “The Imam must be infallible and infallibility is not from the physical features and then he becomes known for that; that is why he has to be mentioned by text”p.132 Ma’ani Al Akhbar

From Abdullah, who said: I said to Abi Abdullah (pbuh): “What is the proof against the illegitimate claimant to this matter?” He said: “Three [things] are from the proof that would not combine in any man except the companion of this matter: that he shall be the first of the people before anyone, that he shall have the weapon of the Messenger of Allah (pbuhahf) and that he becomes the Companion of the Apparent Will. It is the [Will] which, if you went to the town and asked the common people and the youths: To whom has So-and-So appointed as a successor? They would reply: To so-and-so.” Imama walTabasir min alHira p.138 h.158

Sheikh AlMufeed: “As for their question about: How can the text be more significant than choosing?The answer: It was as such because the condition of an Imam is that he is the best from Allah and the most knowledgeable one is the bravest and righteous. And that is because it is not known who is deserving for it[the Imamate] by determining it through the mind and intuition. And so it is proven that there is no way to it except by the text from the one who knows the secrets(i.e. Allah swt) and stopping at that. And also: The Imam must be infallible like the infallibility of the Prophet s.a.w.w and there is no way to knowing infallibility except by the way of the truthful text from Allah or unchallengeable knowledge that is beyond the norms. Masael AlAkabrya p.52

وقال الشيخ المفيد رحمه الله:

(فصل: وأما مسألتهم من أين صار النص أولى من الاختيار؟ فالجواب أنه كان كذلك؛ لأنّ من شرط الإمام أنه الأفضل عند الله والأعلم الأشجع الأصلح، وذلك مما لا يعلم المستحق له على التعيين بالعقل ولا بالحدس، فثبت أنه لا طريق إليه إلا بالنص من العالم بالسرائر، والتوقيف منه عليه. وأيضاً: فإن الإمام يجب أن يكون معصوماً كعصمة النبي ص ولا طريق إلى العلم بالعصمة إلا من جهة النص من صادق عن الله، أو علم معجز خارق للعادات) المسائل العكبرية: ص52.

Sheikh AlSaadoq also said:”We knew that the Imam has to be infallible and we observed that if infallibity is necessary, he has to be textualized from the Prophet s.a.w.w about him because infallibity is not from the physical features and then the creation knows by observing. So it is necessary that the knower of the unseen, the Mighty and Most High textualizes about him through the tongue of His Prophet s.a.w.w and that is because the Imam must be textualized. And authenticity about the Proofs have been correct according to what we have clarified and narrated from the correct reports.” Maani AlAkhbar p.136

وقال أيضاً: (…دللنا على أن الإمام لا يكون إلا معصوماً وأرينا إنه إذا وجبت العصمة في الإمام لم يكن بد من أن ينص النبي صلى الله عليه واله عليه لأن العصمة ليست في ظاهر الخلقة فيعرفها الخلق بالمشاهدة فواجب أن ينص عليها علام الغيوب تبارك وتعالى على لسان نبيه صلى الله عليه واله وذلك لأن الإمام لا يكون إلا منصوصاً عليه. وقد صح لنا النص بما بيناه من الحجج وبما رويناه من الأخبار الصحيحة…) معاني الأخبار ص 136.

Sheikh AlMiqdad in his comment, Ch.11: “I say: This is an indication that the way of determining the Imam, there is a consensus(Ijma) that the textualization is from Allah and His Messenger or from a preceding Imam, is an independent cause upon determining the Imam. But the point of contention is, can determining him happen without a text or not. So our companions from the Imamya denied that and said there is no way except by the TEXT” Sharh AlBaab AlHaadi Ashar p.94-95 by Miqdad AlSayoori

قال الشيخ المقداد في تعليق الباب الحادي عشر : (( أقول : هذا إشارة إلى طريق تعيين الإمام وقد حصل الإجماع على أن التنصيص من الله ورسوله أو من إمام سابق سبب مستقل في تعيين الإمام وإنما الخلاف في انه هل يحصل تعيينه بسبب غير النص أم لا ؟ فمنع أصحابنا الأمامية من ذلك وقالوا لا طريق إلا النص )). (على أن التنصيص من الله ورسوله أو من إمام سابق سبب مستقل في تعيين الإمام

شرح الباب الحادي عشر: ص94 – 95.

Sheikh AlSaadoq:”It will not harm them whoever disconnects from them or turns away from them if they were textualized from Allah by the tongue of the prophet s.a.w.w” Kamal AlDeen p.247

قال الشيخ الصدوق (رحمه الله) في وصف الأئمة (ع): (…لا يضرهم قطع من قطعهم ولا إدبار من أدبر عنهم إذ كانوا من قبل الله منصوصاً عليهم على لسان نبي الله صلى الله عليه وآله) كمال الدين وتمام النعمة ص 247.

AlHarth ibn Al-Mugheera he said to Abi Abdullah (Imam Jafer) a.s: “How do we know about Saaheb Al-Amr(companion of the matter)? he said: “peacefulness, dignity, knowledge, and the will.” Basa’er Al-Darajat Muhammad ibn Al-Hassan Al-Safar p.509 Al-Kafi v.1 p.378 Bihar Al-Anwar v.62 p.217

Weapon ie. Knowledge: From Safwan from Abi AlHassan AlRitha pbuh he said: Abu Jaafersaid: “The weapon to us is like the Covenant of Banu Isra’el, wherever the Covenant is around, the Prophethood is inherited and wherever the weapon is placed it is when the matter unfolds, I said: Is the weapon separated from knowledge?He said:No” v.1 p.238 AlKafi

Imam Ritha(a.s)in the court of Mamoon, when someone asked him and said: “O son of the Messenger of Allah, in what way the Imamate will be correct by the claimer? He said pbuh(a.s): By the text and the evidence, he said to him: And the evidence of the Imam is what? He said pbuh: In knowledge and answering the request. Uyoon Akhbar AlRitha(a.s) v.2 p.216

From Abi AlJarood he said: “I said to Abi Jaafer pbuh, when its time for the Imam that will rise from Ahlulbayt, how would the one that comes after him be known? He said: With guidance and knowledge and the approval of the family of Muhammad about his virtue and he will not be asked between the two covers except that he answers” Imama WalTabsera p.137

Banner: Imam Jaafer(a.s)said: “For us, Ahlulbayt is a banner whoever transgresses against it is an evil one and whoever is late to follow it is misguided and whoever followed it is guided, it will be written on it “AlBaya Lila pledging allegiance is to Allah” 250 signs p.15 Sheikh Korani

Shaykh Mufid (ra) has narrated from Imam Jafar al-Sadiq (as): “Jibril (as) will call out by the end of his right hand Al Bay’ah Lillah……” This Riwayah can be found in Al-Irshad, V 2, P 379 and in Dala’el al-Imamah, P250 and Kitab al-ghaybah, P453 and in the book Rowdha al-waezin, P262

Detailed Hadith: Reported from Ali son of Mihzyar that Abu Jafar(Al-Jawad pbuh) said: “As if I can see the Qaem on the day of Ashura on a Saturday, standing between Al-Rukn and Al-Maqam, while infront of him is Gabriel pbuh calling,‘Allegiance is to Allah (Albayatolilah).’ So then he fills the earth with justice just as it was filled with injustice and tyranny.” -Gaibat Al-Tusi page 453 h.459

Abu Abdullah a.s he said: “Do you think the one that chooses a successor can choose whoever he needs? No by Allah! It is a promise/covenant from Allah and Messenger (s), man to a man, until the matter ends to the companion of it” v.1 p.307 Kafi

Scroll to Top