Taqleed of fallible is an innovation
Taqleed of a non-infallible is a prevalent innovation practised in our age. This post shows hadiths from Ahlulbayt pbut and statement of Ahmed Alhasan against the same. Ahmed Alhasan (Facebook Posts): “Their clerical religion with which they deceived and wish to continue deceiving the Shia of the progeny of Muhammad is built upon the ideology that the non-infallible must be imitated. They do not have narrative proof for this, and their clerics acknowledge this matter. They do not have a verse with explicit proof or a narration of definitive proof and a definitive chain of narrators. And you can refer to the statements of Sayyed al-Khoei and Sayyed al-Khomeini (May Allah have mercy upon them) and the statements of other clerics concerning this issue.Consequently, today these people move toward rational proof, which is that the ignorant one must refer to the knowledgeable one. And I have refuted this proof of theirs with a complete refutation and I clarified that it is as you said, weaker than the home of the spider, as they presume and present presumptions out of their own effort and they admit to this, and none of them professes that he presents certitude.Therefore, the [rational] proof does not apply to them because they are not people of knowledge who present proof in order for the ignorant one to refer to them, as only the vicegerents of Allah are knowledgeable ones who present certitude and who must be referred to, according to reason. This is what we say; imitating the infallible is the only thing that is obligatory. And when they find that the aforementioned does not help them prove their ideology, they try to deceive the public by saying that the proof for their ideology which is that the non-infallible or the clerics must be imitated, is that the non-specialized one consults the specialized one. And this presentation of theirs has demolished their false ideology in a way that they do not realize. {And they thought that their fortresses would protect them from Allah, but Allah came upon them from where they had not expected, and He cast terror into their hearts. They destroyed their houses by their own hands and the hands of the believers. So take warning, O people of insight.} Surat al-Hashr (Exile) 59:2. So the most that can be said concerning the specialized one being consulted by the non-specialized one is that it is a permissible consultation and not an obligatory one. This means that by their presentation of this statement as proof of their ideology, they relinquish their false ideology, which is that imitating the non-infallible or the clerics is obligatory.They give you the example of the patient consulting the doctor in order to prove their ideology of imitating the non-infallible or the clerics, whereas the patient consulting the doctor and doing as he says is not obligatory, but rather it is permissible. So if you become sick, must you go to the doctor and must you do as he says?! The doctor himself sometimes makes presumptuous verdicts and tells you that these are the chances of success and those are the chances of failure and that you have a choice to make. He doesn’t tell you that you must do as he says or that you must take the medicine he prescribes or that you must undergo the operation that he thinks can cure you. Many patients have died at the hands of doctors in operating rooms or due to a mistake by the doctor in determining the type or dosage of a medication. And some patients have visited the doctor when experiencing some pain, only to leave paralyzed and unable to stand due to a mistake made by the surgeon who has a doctorate of medicine for determining the size of the metal alloy plate required to fix the bones. Consequently, I do not believe that a rational person would say that it is obligatory for a patient to consult a doctor and do as he says. So now, is there one among those who call themselves “clerics” who has the honor and the courage to admit before everyone that they lost to Ahmed Alhasan and that their ideology, upon which the clerics’ religion is built, has been demolished and that it is over? Whoever has the honor and courage to acknowledge the truth should acknowledge and admit that Ahmed Alhasan has demolished their ideology and that it was moved to the garbage dump of history with no return. Yes, it remains for now as a means of ignorance, deceiving the Shia of Ahlulbayt and making them ignorant. But it has ended, and it no longer has any scientific credibility with those who request to know the truth. Sooner or later, a day will come in which the Shia of Ahlulbayt will take notice and they will know that the impostor is the one requesting from them that they believe that imitating the non-infallible or the clerics is obligatory, since he is commanding them to believe in a false ideology that has no proof, whether from narrations or by reason. And I repeat: (obligatory) so that you may pay attention, open your eyes and see well O Shia, may Allah support you, and so that those who call themselves “clerics” may pay attention to their statement that it is obligatory to imitate the non-infallible or the clerics. Therefore, let them prove this obligation to us after their proofs have been refuted and clarified to be as you described, (weaker than the home of a spider). Do not let those people deceive you into directing the argument toward discussing ijtihad or the permissibility of imitation or the proof behind acting according to what they presume, as all of these matters come from their false ideology which they are requested to prove. Therefore, their ideology is the obligation of imitating the non-infallible, then let them prove it or acknowledge its falsehood and acknowledge that Ahmed Alhasan demolished it, crushed the height
Taqleed of fallible is an innovation Read More »
