Yamani Misconceptions

Taqleed of fallible is an innovation

Taqleed of a non-infallible is a prevalent innovation practised in our age. This post shows hadiths from Ahlulbayt pbut and statement of Ahmed Alhasan against the same. Ahmed Alhasan (Facebook Posts): “Their clerical religion with which they deceived and wish to continue deceiving the Shia of the progeny of Muhammad is built upon the ideology that the non-infallible must be imitated. They do not have narrative proof for this, and their clerics acknowledge this matter. They do not have a verse with explicit proof or a narration of definitive proof and a definitive chain of narrators. And you can refer to the statements of Sayyed al-Khoei and Sayyed al-Khomeini (May Allah have mercy upon them) and the statements of other clerics concerning this issue.Consequently, today these people move toward rational proof, which is that the ignorant one must refer to the knowledgeable one. And I have refuted this proof of theirs with a complete refutation and I clarified that it is as you said, weaker than the home of the spider, as they presume and present presumptions out of their own effort and they admit to this, and none of them professes that he presents certitude.Therefore, the [rational] proof does not apply to them because they are not people of knowledge who present proof in order for the ignorant one to refer to them, as only the vicegerents of Allah are knowledgeable ones who present certitude and who must be referred to, according to reason. This is what we say; imitating the infallible is the only thing that is obligatory. And when they find that the aforementioned does not help them prove their ideology, they try to deceive the public by saying that the proof for their ideology which is that the non-infallible or the clerics must be imitated, is that the non-specialized one consults the specialized one. And this presentation of theirs has demolished their false ideology in a way that they do not realize. {And they thought that their fortresses would protect them from Allah, but Allah came upon them from where they had not expected, and He cast terror into their hearts. They destroyed their houses by their own hands and the hands of the believers. So take warning, O people of insight.} Surat al-Hashr (Exile) 59:2.  So the most that can be said concerning the specialized one being consulted by the non-specialized one is that it is a permissible consultation and not an obligatory one. This means that by their presentation of this statement as proof of their ideology, they relinquish their false ideology, which is that imitating the non-infallible or the clerics is obligatory.They give you the example of the patient consulting the doctor in order to prove their ideology of imitating the non-infallible or the clerics, whereas the patient consulting the doctor and doing as he says is not obligatory, but rather it is permissible. So if you become sick, must you go to the doctor and must you do as he says?! The doctor himself sometimes makes presumptuous verdicts and tells you that these are the chances of success and those are the chances of failure and that you have a choice to make. He doesn’t tell you that you must do as he says or that you must take the medicine he prescribes or that you must undergo the operation that he thinks can cure you. Many patients have died at the hands of doctors in operating rooms or due to a mistake by the doctor in determining the type or dosage of a medication. And some patients have visited the doctor when experiencing some pain, only to leave paralyzed and unable to stand due to a mistake made by the surgeon who has a doctorate of medicine for determining the size of the metal alloy plate required to fix the bones. Consequently, I do not believe that a rational person would say that it is obligatory for a patient to consult a doctor and do as he says. So now, is there one among those who call themselves “clerics” who has the honor and the courage to admit before everyone that they lost to Ahmed Alhasan and that their ideology, upon which the clerics’ religion is built, has been demolished and that it is over? Whoever has the honor and courage to acknowledge the truth should acknowledge and admit that Ahmed Alhasan has demolished their ideology and that it was moved to the garbage dump of history with no return. Yes, it remains for now as a means of ignorance, deceiving the Shia of Ahlulbayt and making them ignorant. But it has ended, and it no longer has any scientific credibility with those who request to know the truth. Sooner or later, a day will come in which the Shia of Ahlulbayt will take notice and they will know that the impostor is the one requesting from them that they believe that imitating the non-infallible or the clerics is obligatory, since he is commanding them to believe in a false ideology that has no proof, whether from narrations or by reason. And I repeat: (obligatory) so that you may pay attention, open your eyes and see well O Shia, may Allah support you, and so that those who call themselves “clerics” may pay attention to their statement that it is obligatory to imitate the non-infallible or the clerics. Therefore, let them prove this obligation to us after their proofs have been refuted and clarified to be as you described, (weaker than the home of a spider). Do not let those people deceive you into directing the argument toward discussing ijtihad or the permissibility of imitation or the proof behind acting according to what they presume, as all of these matters come from their false ideology which they are requested to prove. Therefore, their ideology is the obligation of imitating the non-infallible, then let them prove it or acknowledge its falsehood and acknowledge that Ahmed Alhasan demolished it, crushed the height

Taqleed of fallible is an innovation Read More »

Can an Imam experience forgetfulness or inattentiveness?

Often at times, we see those who are opposing the call saying that an infallible is 100 percent in everything, almost as if they are not humans and would justify that they don’t forget at all. This hadeeth shows us that an infallible can forget as it is normal, for even the Quran pointed out that Joshua a.s. forgot the fish and Moses a.s. and also Adam a.s. Them being infallibles is not harmed or let down from them forgetting because they are ultimately humans. Allah SWT is the one who is 100 percent perfect who doesn’t forget and doesn’t sleep. There was even a case where Imam Ritha pbuh cursed those from the people of Kufa who believed that the Prophet s.a.w.w doesn’t become inattentive and replied that only Allah SWT doesn’t become inattentive. So now according to the scholar followers are they going to nullify Imam Saadiq’s infallibility? Imam Jafar pbuh said: “So the Messenger pbuhap commanded Ali pbuh and Salman and Aba Thar and I FORGOT THE REST I THINK ITS MIQDAD..to call in the mosque with the highest of their voices that there is no faith to who does not secure his neighbor from the evil things. So they called three times and then he[Prophet] pointed to every 40 houses, in front of him and behind him, at his right and at his left. Kafi v.3 قال: فأمر رسول الله صلى اللهعليه وآله علياا عليه السلام وسلمان وأباذر ونسيت آخر وأظنه المقداد أن ينادوا في المسجد بأعلى أصواتهم بأنه لا إيمان لمن لم يأمن جاره بوائقه ; فنادوا بها ثلاثا ثم أو مأبيده إلى كل أربعين دارا من بين يديه ومن خلفه وعن يمينه وعن شماله. From Muhammad son of Muslim saying: I heard Abu Abdullah (as): Sufyani will rule over, after appearing for 5 places (Damascus, Homs, Palestine, Jordan, Qunsoreen) after the duration of a woman’s pregnancy. Then he said: “Istagforalla! A camel’s pregnancy, and it’s a guaranteed matter, it must occur”(Camel’s duration of pregnancy is 13 months) Gaibat AlToosi p.449

Can an Imam experience forgetfulness or inattentiveness? Read More »

Misconception about the Dajjal from Dijlat AlBasra

Question: Salam alaikum wa rahmatollah to all Ansar. May Allah bless you all. Im a new ansar from Malaysia, as I am new, I donot have sufficient knowledge to answer all question posed by Malaysian Shia. Today someone gave me Kurani new book, Dajjal of Basrah, http://www.alameli.net/books/index.php?book=119&part=1 I have a very poor Arabic, so all I want to know, does the point in the book is valid? Thanks Answer: Salam Alaikom wr wb There is no Dajjal from Basra there is Dajjal from Dijlat Al Basra this is the biggest invalid point made from Korani. He said that the Dajjal is from Basra and that is not what the hadeeth said. Dijla means the tigris river of Basra and that is in Meesan. Haydar Imshatat was the first to claim that he is Imam Ahmad Al Hassan AlYamani and then he perished after a Mubahala with Imam Ahmad Al Hassan a.s. Haydar Imshatat is the Dajjal from Dijlat Al Basra and claimed that he is the Yamani. Haydar Imshatat used to be an ansar and among the close ansars to Imam Ahmad Al Hassan(a.s) and then he left Imam Ahmad Al hassan a.s. and claimed he is the Yamani and lied to the people.Imam Ahmad AlHassan called him for a Mubahala so after when the Mubahala happened between Imam Ahmad Al Hassan and Haydar Imshatat, Haydar perished and died in a few days after the U.S. troops shot him down. Imam Ali (pbuhaf):“… And be careful of the Dajjals from the children of Fatima. Indeed there are some from the children of Fatima who are Dajjals. One Dajjal will come from the Tigris(Dijla) of Basra, and he is not from me, and he is the first of all the Dajjals.” Ref: Malahim wal fitan by Ibn Tawoos, P. 249 (chapter 37, hadith no. 362) Tigris of Basra starts from Mesaan and Euphrates starts from Nasirya. Shatt AlArab is a confluence of the Euphrates and the Tigris: This book unfortunately is packed full of falsehood against the Yamani and misguiding the many readers. Claims like the Yamani is a zionist, Baathist, imposter. All of these lies to mislead people away from the true Yamani Imam Ahmad Al-Hasan PBUH. InshAllah if you watch the video it will totally refute the lie that was made against the Yamani PBUH Imam Ahmad Al Hasan. Additionally, Imam Ahmad Al-Hasan presented his proofs and evidences in his books and unfortunately Sheikh Korani did not find a way to refute the evidences and the Yamani’s knowledge so he resorted to this useless tactic which is to call the Yamani a Dajjal. And what is more tragic to his conclusion is that he did not read the hadith clearly and couldn’t compare between Dajjal from Dijlat Al Basra and Dajjal from Basra. InshAllah in the aforemention readings that I posted will clarify much of this misconception. This is the same tool that the Wahabis have used against Imam Al Mahdi a.s. the 12th Imam(a.s). And the Christians against the Prophet(saw) in which they search for all the means they can to blindly fight the message from spreading to the world before investigating,researching and inquiring. Imam Ahmad PBUH does not want blind followers he wants people of knowledge to follow him.

Misconception about the Dajjal from Dijlat AlBasra Read More »

Response to: “After them there will be 12 Mahdis”

There has been a misconception raised over the issue of this part of the hadeeth in the Prophet’s will:These are the twelve Imams. Then there will be twelve Mahdi’s after them. then when Allah receiveth him, let him hand it over to his son, the first of the close ones, he has three names, one like mine and my Father’s: Abdollah (Servant of God), Ahmad and the third name is The Mahdi (the guided) and he is the first Believer” The one with the confusion and misconception is saying that the 12th Imam pbuh didn’t appear yet so that Ahmed can be the first Mahdi and Masoom and the successor of Imam AlMahdi a.s. Our answer: The will of the Prophet Muhammad s.a.w itself says the following:: يا علي ، إنه سيكون بعدي اثنا عشر إماماً ، ومن بعدهم اثنا عشر مهدياً Prophet Muhammad s.a.w said:”O Ali, there shall be after me 12 Imams and after them shall be 12 Mahdis” Gaibat AlToosi p.150-151 In here the Prophet s.a.w said that “there shall be after me 12 Imams” so we would ask this question to the one with the misconception/confusion: was Ali pbuh not a successor and Masoom during the Prophet’s time and during his Gaiba and after his Gaiba even after when the Prophet s.a.w said that there shall be 12 Imams are after him and Ali is the first Imam? If he was, then what is the problem if the first Mahdi is masoom and a successor during the lifetime of Imam AlMahdi a.s. and during the Gaiba of Imam AlMahdi a.s. and during the appearance of Imam AlMahdi a.s. and after the death of Imam AlMahdi a.s.? If Imam Ali a.s. was a successor and masoom during the Prophet’s lifetime and Gaiba and after his death, why doesn’t it apply according to your logic to Ahmed the first Mahdi??!! Imam Ali pbuh said:O people!There was for me from the Messenger of Allah s.a.w 10 qualities it is more beloved to me then what the sun rises for:The Messenger of Allahs .a.w said to me:”O Ali, you are my brother in this world and the hereafter and you are the most closest of the creations to me on the Day of Judgement on the encounter between the hands of the Conqueror. And your dwelling place in paradise faces my dwelling place like how the dwelling places of the brothers in Allah the Exalted and Mighty. And you are the Waarith(inheritor)of me and you are my executor after me on my Idaati and affair and you are the preserver for me on my family during my OCCULTATION(GAIBA) and you are the Imam of my nation and the Riser with justice upon my people and my guardian is the guardian of Allah and your enemy is my enemy and my enemy is the enemy of Allah”v.8 p.212 Mawsooat AlImam Ali Ibn Abi Taleb, Muhammad AlRayshahri كان لي من رسول الله عشر خصال 3658 – الإمام علي (عليه السلام): أيها الناس! إنه كان لي من رسول الله (صلى الله عليه وآله) عشر خصال، هن أحب إلي مما طلعت عليه الشمس؛ قال لي رسول الله (صلى الله عليه وآله): يا علي، أنت أخي في الدنيا والآخرة، وأنت أقرب الخلائق إلي يوم القيامة في الموقف بين يدي الجبار، ومنزلك في الجنة مواجه منزلي كما يتواجه منازل الإخوان في الله عز وجل، وأنت الوارث مني، وأنت الوصي من بعدي في عداتي وأمري، وأنت الحافظ لي في أهلي عند غيبتي، وأنت الإمام لأمتي، والقائم بالقسط في رعيتي، وأنت وليي، ووليي ولي الله، وعدوك عدوي، وعدوي عدو اللهhttp://shiaonlinelibrary.com/%D8%A7%D9% … %D8%A9_208 So here Imam Ali a.s. has a task from the Prophet s.a.w even during his Gaiba and the Prophet’s will says:Prophet Muhammad s.a.w said:”O Ali, there shall be after me 12 Imams and after them shall be 12 Mahdis” Gaibat AlToosi p.150-151 So is Imam Ali a.s. not masoom and not infallible according to your logic? If he was masoom and infallible during the Gaiba of the Prophet s.a.w then rest your case for Ahmed is masoom and infallible during the Gaiba of Imam AlMahdi a.s. and the Prophet’s will said: “and after them shall be 12 Mahdis” so the first Mahdi is described as a first believer and first of the close ones, so he is the first of the 313 and there is no better to pave the way for Imam AlMahdi a.s. before he appears than this man “Ahmed” the son of Imam AlMahdi a.s., so he is the best of the companions and there are hadeeths which says خروج ناس من المشرق يوطئون للمهدي سلطانه. رووه في كتب أهل السنّة منها [1] «سنن ابن ماجة» ج9 ص915 “Emergence of the people from the East who will facilitate for the Mahdi his kingdom” so there are people who will facilitate for the Mahdi a.s. coming from the East and the man of the banners and the first of the close ones and the successor will be obligated with such a task. And also there is a Mawla(Master)who will succeed the affair of Imam AlMahdi a.s as he knows the place of the Mahdi a.s.during the long occultation and someone to succeed or come after his affair is a masoom. The Lafth(enunciation)that Sheikh AlToosi approved of in his Gaiba it does not proceed to a possibility of Tas’heef(something incorrectly written) or Tahreef(fabrication), contrary to the existent text right now in Gaibat AlSheikh AlNumani. Narrated by Sheikh AlNumani the student of the Thiqa of Islam AlKulainy in the Book of AlGaiba and Sheikh AlToosi in his book AlGaiba with two reliable Sanads from AlMufathel son of Umar he said: I heard Aba Abdullah pbuh saying:”The companion of the affair has two occultations, one of them will be long until some of them say that he died and some of them will say he is still and some of them will say he left until nothing remains on his affair from his companions except a small part of his companions and no one will know

Response to: “After them there will be 12 Mahdis” Read More »

Response to “Raja comes after Imam Al-Mahdi not Ahmed”

The one with the misconception and confusion would say that Hussain a.s. comes after Imam AlMahdi pbuh and not Ahmed and since this is the case the Question will be as follows:”Is there a hadeeth which says that after the Mahdi MUHAMMAD SON OF ALHASAN A.S. (emphasizing the name) Hussain a.s. will rise and bury him when he dies? There isn’t a single hadeeth mentioning that Hussain a.s. will bury the one with name of the Imam that we mentioned except Mahdi or Riser in the hadeeths and Imam Ritha a.s. explained this so well when he was asked this question before.Ali son of Abi Hamza AlBata’eni said to Imam Ritha pbuh “We narrated that the Imam will not pass away until he sees his offspring.He said Abu AlHassan(AlRitha pbuh): Did you narrate a different hadeeth than this? He said: No. He said: Yes by Allah you have narrated, except the Riser and you do not know what it means and to whom it was referring to. So Ali Ibn Hamza said:Yes by Allah, this is in the hadeeth. Abu AlHasan a.s. said: Woe onto you, how can you be so sure about something when you left some of it.And then he said: O Sheikh fear Allah and do not be from among those avoiding the religion of Allah.v.2 p.73 Mirza AlNoori Najm AlThaqib وروى بسنده عن اسماعيل بن سهل عن بعض أصحابنا حديثاً طويلاً عرض فيه النقاش الدائر بين البطائني والامام الرضا (ع) حول إمامته. وجاء في آخره: أن البطائني قال: «إنا روينا أن الامام لا يمضي حتى يرى عقبه. فقال أبو الحسن (ع): أما رويتم في هذا الحديث غير هذا. قال: لا. قال (ع): بلى واللّه لقد رويتم إلا القائم، وأنتم لا تدرون ما معناه، ولمَ قيل. قال له علي: بلى واللّه إن هذا لفي الحديث. قال له ابو الحسن (ع): ويلك كيف اجترأت على شيء تدع بعضه. ثم قال: يا شيخ إتق اللّه، ولا تكن من الصادين عن دين اللّه تعالى» http://www.alseraj.net/maktaba/kotob/re … s/a31.html So pay attention to this part”And you do not know what it means to whom it was referring to” if it was talking about Imam Al Mahdi a.s. it wouldn’t have been hidden from a man like Ali son of Abi Hamza AlBata’eni who excelled in memorizing the narrations of Ahlulbayt a.s. And how can it be hidden from him and most of the people around that time knew that the Riser that is being discussed is the Imam Al Mahdi a.s. So since the meaning is “no offspring for him” was hidden from Ali son of Abi Hamza AlBata’ini and the rest from the narrators, it must be meant to someone different than Imam Al Mahdi pbuh and he is the last of the Mahdis from the offspring of Imam Al Mahdi a.s. which is the meaning that was intended from Imam Al Ritha a.s. when he said “and you do not know to whom it was referred to and what it was meant” Bihar Al Anwar v.48 p.270 Its clear from many hadeeths(who wants to review this can read the 100 hadeeths thread and the supplications) that Imam AlMahdi a.s. has an offspring, so this Mahdi is not Imam AlMahdi a.s. Muhammad son of AlHasan. The one whom during his time-that the Raja[Return] will take place and Imam Hussain a.s. will burry him- is the last Mahdi the 12th Mahdi pbuh who has no offspring. عن الحسن بن علي الخزاز قال دخل علي بن أبي حمزة على أبي الحسن الرضا عليه السلام فقال له أنت إمام قال نعم قال فإني سمعت جدك جعفر بن محمد يقول لا يكون الإمام إلا و له عقب فقال له أ نسيت يا شيخ أم تناسيت ليس هكذا قال جعفر إنما قال لا يكون الإمام إلا و له ولد إلا الإمام الذي يخرج عليه الحسين بن علي فإنه لا عقب له قال صدقت جعلني الله فداك هكذا سمعت جدك يقول Mirza AlNoori in Najm AlThaaqib v.2 p.73 After when he mentioned 12 evidences about the offspring of Imam AlMahdi a.s. he said(….and there isn’t a report that conflicts with these reports except the hadeeth that the Thiqa Sheikh who is grand AlFathel Ibn Shaathan AlNaysaboori in his Gaiba with a Sanad that is Saheeh from AlHasan son of Hazaz..he said: I entered to Ali ibn Abi Hamza who was with Abi alHasan alRidha (as), he told him (as): Are you an Imam? He (as) said: “Yes.” So he said: I heard you grandfather Ja’far bin Muhammad (as) say: There will not be an Imam unless he has descendants. So he (as) said: “Did you forget, O Sheikh (old person), or did you try to forget? This is not what Ja’far (as) said, rather Ja’far (as) said: There will not be an Imam unless he has descendants, except the Imam that alHussain bin Ali (as) emerges to, he has no descendants.” So he said to him (as): You have told the truth, may I be your ransom, this is what I heard your grandfather saying. Ghaiba alTusi, p.224, Hadith.188: From alHasan bin Ali alKhazaz, he said: I entered to Ali ibn Abi Hamza who was with Abi alHasan alRidha (as), he told him (as): Are you an Imam? He (as) said: “Yes.” So he said: I heard you grandfather Ja’far bin Muhammad (as) say: There will not be an Imam unless he has descendants. So he (as) said: “Did you forget, O Sheikh (old person), or did you try to forget? This is not what Ja’far (as) said, rather Ja’far (as) said: There will not be an Imam unless he has descendants, except the Imam that alHussain bin Ali (as) emerges to, he has no descendants.” So he said to him (as): You have told the truth, may I be your ransom, this is what I heard your grandfather saying. .Imam Al Saadeq pbuh said:”After the Riser there will be 12 Mahdis from the son of Hussein” p.385/Burhan v.3 p.310/Bihar AlAnwar v.53 p.148 Imam Al Saadeq pbuh said:”After the Riser there will be 11 Mahdis from

Response to “Raja comes after Imam Al-Mahdi not Ahmed” Read More »

Response to Sufyani, Khorasani, Yamani in One Day

Imam Al Baqer pbuh said:”The emergence of the Sufyani, Yamani and Khurasani is in one year, in one month, in one day, ordered like the order of beads,some people will follow some of them and there will be misery on every face, woe to those who stayed far away from them and there is no banner more guided than the banner of the Yamani, his banner is the banner of guidance because he calls/ invites to your Companion/Sahib(Sahib al Zaman a.s), so if the Yamani emerges he will make arms dealing forbidden for the people and every Muslim, and if the Yamani emerges then rise up towards him,indeed his banner is the banner of guidance, and it is not permitted for a Muslim to turn away from him,and whoever does this then he is from the people of the hellfire,because he calls/invites to the truth and to the straight path”p.264 Gaibat Al Numani قال الامام الباقر ع خروج السفياني واليماني والخرساني في سنة واحدة في شهر واحد في يوم واحد نظام كنظام الخرز يتبع بعضه بعضا فيكون الياس من كل وجه بحار الانوار ج 52/208Imam Al-Baqer a.s said:”Khorooj” Emergence of Sufyani,Yamani,Al-Khurasani in one year,one month,and in one day,arranged like the beeds (in a string) one follows the other,and so then despair will be in every direction.Bihar Al-Anwar v.52 p.208Difference between Thohoor and Khurooj:Meaning of Khurooj”emergence”: When Yamani,Sufyani,Khorasani all prepare themselves so they can go to war or when war/battle begins it happens in one day or one month or one year.Meaning of Thohoor”appearance”:When Yamani,Sufyani,Khurasani appear before Khurooj, they will take years in order to gather their troops and followers before heading to battle. Similarly, Prophet Muhammad s.a.w appeared with his call alone and then Imam Ali a.s. was the first to follow him and then he spent 13 years preaching until 313 companions were with him and THEN he made khurooj against the disbelievers. So it takes a long process before the Prophet s.a.w makes khurooj to go to war and battle.Ahmad Al-Hassan a.s has appeared but did not make khurooj yet against the enemies until Allah swt permits it. He will make khurooj when Imam Al-Mahdi a.s orders him and when the Halaqa”the complete round of the Mahdi victors” are present.Imam Jaafer son of Muammad a.s:”The Riser will not emerge until the round completes”.So I said:”How much is that round?”.He said:10,000p.361 v.52 Bihar AlAnwar Gaibat Al Numani p.307-308So the Yamani will take time to gather this amount of great believers because not all Shias will accept the Imam pbuh and there will be a severe trial with the Yamani. Anyhow,Ahmed AlHasan pbuh said:“The narration says that the Yamani is the man of the banner or commander of an army and says that if he emerges its obligatory to stand to him or fight with him, so is it conceivable for a person to fight with a commander and he did not pledge allegiance to him before and believe in him?” “Do you think that they will appear and prepare their armies and fight with many armies during 24 hours for example? Does the mind accept this understanding?” Virtuous servant volume 2 p.47 And this hadeeth proves the point that was made, the Yamani appears before the Sufyani but will make Khorooj(fight him)on the same day. Imam Al Sadeq a.s:”Before the Sufyani is an Egyptian and a Yamani” Bihar Al Anwar v.52 p.210

Response to Sufyani, Khorasani, Yamani in One Day Read More »

How can the successor come before 12th Imam?

The opponents of the call often raise a misconception that if it’s mentioned in the Will of Prophet Muhammad that the 12th Imam pbuh passes it to his successor Ahmed pbuh, the first Mahdi from his progeny when the death comes to him. So how come the successor even appear before the return of 12th Imam? This is the part from the Will: “So if God receives him, let him hand it over to his son, the first of the close ones. He has three names, one like mine and my father’s: Abdullah (servant of God), Ahmed, and the third name is al-Mahdi. He is the first of the believers.” Ghaybat Al Tousi (Occultation by Al Tousi) page 96, page 150 The response is simply that the original word used in the Will in Arabic is Wafah, and Wafah doesn’t always mean death. In fact, Wafah is derived from the word Istifaa which means ‘to take away‘. Hence, we find that Wafah in the Quran has been used for Allah SWT taking Jesus pbuh, and it is an established belief among Muslims that Jesus has not died yet. [Mention] when Allah said, “O Jesus, indeed I will take you and raise you to Myself (Quran 3:55)Ith qala Allahu yaAAeesa innee mutawaffeeka  Wafah has also been used for Allah SWT taking the souls of people during the sleep. And it is He who takes your souls by night and knows what you have committed by day. (Quran 3:55)Wahuwa allathee yatawaffakumbillayli wayaAAlamu ma jarahtum So it is incorrect to restrict the meaning of Wafah to physical death. The truth is that the command to the successor Ahmed is passed during the longer occultation, as the Wafah of 12th Imam pbuh when passing command to his successor Ahmed is just like Wafah of Jesus mentioned in the Holy Quran. Both of them have not died yet and yet the command passed to their successors. Also, since the 12th Imam pbuh is still living, he pbuh continues to be the Imam and the Hujjah (Proof) of Allah SWT, while the successor Ahmed is the Hujjah (proof) from the 12th Imam pbuh upon the people. He simply performs the tasks assigned by the 12th Imam pbuh. This is the reason that the successor Ahmed is also called ‘First of the believers‘. It means that Ahmed will be the first to believe in the 12th Imam pbuh, and therefore, he must be present before the rise of 12th Imam pbuh. Because if he was going to be born after the rise of the 12th Imam pbuh, then the title “First of the Believers” would not apply to him! This is also confirmed through various other hadiths from the Ahlulbayt pbut. For example, the following hadith shows that the successor of 12th Imam pbuh is present during the longer occultation: Imam Al-Sadiq pbuh said: The companion of the affair has two occultations. One of them will be long until some of them will say that he was killed, and some of them will say that he left, until nothing is left from his affair from his companions except a few of his companions. And no one will know about his location from his children or other than that except the Mawla who will succeed his affair.Gaibat AlToosi p.162 The following hadith from Kitab Sulaym Ibn Qays also shows that the father of Mahdi comes after him. Prophet Muhammad pbuhap said after he placed his hand on Hussein pbuh: O Salman! Mahdi of my nation who will spread the world with justice and tranquility after it has been filled with oppression and inequality is from this son. Imam after Imam, a scholar son of a scholar, a successor son of a successor. His father who comes after him is an Imam and a successor and a scholar. Then it was asked, ‘O Prophet of Allah, is the Mahdi better or his father?’ He replied: ‘His father is better than him. The first one has all their rewards because Allah SWT guided them by him.” Kitab Sulaym Ibn Qais page 429 This Mahdi in the above hadith can’t be the 12th Imam, as his father Hasan Al-Askari had already achieved martyrdom and doesn’t come after him. This applies to none other than First Mahdi Ahmed who is present in longer occultation and his father, the 12th Imam pbuh comes after him.

How can the successor come before 12th Imam? Read More »

Is Will of Prophet Muhammad authentic?

The Will of Prophet Muhammad (p) is absolute in authenticity. It is Tawatur based on the method of Ilm Al-Diraya. Tawatur means that the multiplicity of the sources of a certain report leads to certitude in the listener that the report is indeed true. It is Mutawatir Manawi, which is Tawatur of the content. It means that the content of the hadith is found in various other hadiths, through similar phrases with different texts. The content of Will of Prophet Muhammad (p) shows that there are 12 Imams and after them 12 Mahdis pbut. It shows that the assignment of hujjat (proof of God) continues after the 12th Imam pbuh. There are about 40 narrations that relay similar content as mentioned in the Will of the Prophet Muhammad (p). There are also more than 100 narrations about the offspring of 12th Imam (p), that further strengthen this report. The references (Qarae’n) related to the meaning of the will far exceed the amount that makes the report Khabar Ahad (Solitary report) or Thani Al Sudoor(doubtful issuance). Sheikh Al-Tusi¹ ² counted this report as Sahih and among the Mutawatir. He reports the will among a small portion of authentic hadiths and says the following about their authenticity: Therefore, the will is Mutawatir Manawi and Qati Al-Sudoor, which means it has a clearcut and authentic source. It is very important to note that a person can’t refute the statement of al-Tousi about the narrators of the hadith of the Will of Prophet Muhammad (p) by presenting the statement of the recent clerics. They and all the clerics after al-Tousi, are dependent upon the statement of al-Tousi concerning the narrators, and can’t go against it. Otherwise, even the crumbs between their hands that they call Ilm Al-Rijal (Biographical Evaluation) will be destroyed. In addition to that, Sheikh Mirza Al-Noori regarded the chain of Prophet’s (s) will as Mutabar (a significant chain). He says in Najm Al-Thaqib volume 2 page 72: “..and Sheikh Al-tusi reported it with a sanad that is authentic(mutabar)..“ Statements of Scholars about 12 Mahdis A. Sheikh Al Sadooq- Kamal alDeen waTamam alNi’ma, p.77 On the matter of Hujjah after 12th Imam pbuh, he says: “It has been mentioned that there will be an Imam after him (12th Imam pbuh) or it will be the Day of Judgment and we are not restricted concerning this except to confirm the Twelve Imams as a belief of what the Twelfth Imam (as) will mention after him.” B. Sheikh Al-Mufeed- Irshad, vol.2, p.387 “There will be no nation/government for anyone after the Qaim’s (as) nation except from what has come to us from the narrations talking about the rise of his (as) son if Allah (swt) wills for this… and Allah SWT knows best what will happen, and He is the Guardian who gives success to the righteous [servants], and Him we ask for protection from misguidance, and we seek guidance through Him towards the path of enlightenment…” C. Sayyed Al-Shareef Al-Murtadha (Sheikh alMufeed’s Student and Sheikh Al-Tusi’s Teacher)- Rasa’il Al-Shareef Al-Murtadha, vol.3, p.145-146 “When the school of thought is knowledgeable that in every era there is always an Imam [leader] who takes care of repairing the religion and conciliating [between] the Muslims, and we do not have authentic evidence that the emergence of the Qaim (as) corresponds to the end of the assignment [of leaders by Allah swt], then the era after him (as) will have a an Imam [leader] in it whose obedience is obligatory, or will not be [obligatory]. Thus if we said: That there exists an Imam after him, we shall exit out of the saying that we are Twelvers; however if we didn’t say that there is an Imam after him, then we would have made void the origin [Asel] which is the pillar of the school of thought, and it is shameful to empty the era without an Imam.” …So it is conceivable that after him (as) there will be Imams that will protect the Religion and they are the conciliators of the people, … and saying this does not exit us out of being named with “The Twelvers”, because this name is given to those who confirm the Imamate [leadership] of the twelve Imams and we [indeed] confirm this; and there is no one more suitable for this school of thought other than us.“ D. Sheikh Al-Tusi- Refer to the first section E. Sheikh Hussain Al-Tabrisi Al-Mirza Al-Noori Al-Mohadith– Najm alThaaqib, vol.2, p.68-72 “As of yet, no one has considered leaving this as one of the characteristics of Imam Mahdi (as) (i.e. no one has considered Imam Mahdi (as) will not have children and wives). We are convinced [that he will] by the mention of [the following] twelve reports/narrations First Narration: Sheikh Al-Nu’mani, the student of alKulaini, and Sheikh Al-Tusi narrated in their Al-Ghaiba books in 2 different considerable Sanad [chain of narrators] from Imam Sadiq (as), he said: “The Companion of the Matter has two occultations, one of them will be so long that some will say ‘he died’, some will say ‘he has been killed’, and some of them will say ‘he left’. Until none from his companions will remain on his matter/affair except a small party, and not one of his children or anyone else will know about his matter except the Mawla who will succeed his matter.” Second Narration: Sheikh al-Tusi narrated from Imam Mahdi (as) in a long Dua, he said:”O Allah give him (Imam Mahdi a.s.) in himself, his offspring, his Shia, his subjects, his close followers, his followers, his enemies and all the people of Earth whatever pleases and satisfies him [blessings for his Shia and defeat for his enemies]” … “And pray upon Your Guardian and the Guardians of his Promise and the Imams from his children…” Third Narration: Ibn Tawus narrated in his book Jamal al-Isbu’ in a Ziarah for Imam Mahdi (as): “May Allah send his prayer upon you and upon your AhlulBayt (family) the purified and pleasant.”

Is Will of Prophet Muhammad authentic? Read More »

Is Yamani from Yemen?

The opponents of the call often use the argument that Yamani has to be Yemen. This is a very superficial misconception. Even a quick reading would remind a reasonable person that surely they must not be talking about the country Yemen which came to be known only in recent history. But that’s not all, let’s dive deep on this misconception: Firstly, Most of the books don’t mention anything about Yamani emerging from Yemen at all. While, some of the editions mention ‘from Yemen’ in parenthesis, and there is no explanation for its addition in the footnotes. Here are the following books that don’t have the phrase ‘from Yemen’ in parenthesis after Yamani: Book: Ilaam AlWara Bi’Alam AlHuda v.2 p.233. The Author quotes Kamal Al-Din, whose Author is Sheikh AlTabrasi, Demise: 548 A.H. Kamal Al-Din doesn’t have the phrase ‘from Yemen‘. Book: Kashf AlGuma. Author: Ibn Abi AlFateh Alarbili. Demise:693 A.H Book: Muntakhab AlAnwar AlMuthea. Author: Sayed Buha AlDeen AlNajafi. Demise:803 A.H. Book: Ithbat Al-Hudat. Author: Muhammad son of Hassan Al-Hur Al-Ameli. Quotes: Kamal Al-Deen. Reference: v.3 p.468 (Nusoos on Imamat Saaheb Al-Zaman). Book: Bihar Al-Anwar. Author: Alama Al-Majlesy. Demise:1111 A.H. Reference: V.51 p.218. Quote from Kamal Al-Deen. Book: Ilzam Al-Naseb Min Ithbaat AlHuja AlGa’eb. Author: Sheikh Ali Al-Yazdi Al-Ha’eri. Demise:1333 A.H. Reference: V.1 P.197 Book: Besharat Al-Islam. Author: Sayed Mustafa Al-Kathemy. Demise:1336 A.H. Print: Qom-Maktabat Alameen. Book: Mikyaal Al-Makaarem. Author: Mirza Muhammad Taqi Al-Asfahany. Demise:1348 A.H. Reference: V.1 P.71 Book: Rijal Tarako Basamat Ala Qismaat Al-Tareekh. Author: Sayed Lateef Al-Qizwaini -Still living. Reference: P.275 Secondly, there are also many narrations about the Yamani coming from ‘East‘. Here is an example:  The Prophet (p) took the hand of Al-Abba[son of Abdulmutalib] and the hand of Ali a.s and said: “There shall be a man from the offspring of this man (Abbas) who shall fill the earth unjustice and tyranny. And there shall be from this man (Ali) who shall spread the earth with justice and tranquility. So if you see this happening, upon you is to go with the man who is the Yamani, for he shall come from the East and he is the one with the banner of the Mahdi” Al-Mahdi Al-Muntather Al-Maw’ood, Door No. 2/ page 207 Thirdly, some narrations mention Prophet Muhammad (p) saying that He is Yamani, even though the Prophet (s) was born in Mecca. Prophet Muhammad pbuhap said: “Belief (Imaan) is Yamani and I am a Yamani” Bihar Al-Anwar V.57 P.232 Fourthly, some narrations mention that even Mecca was considered from Yemen, and hence the Kaaba was called Yemeni Kaaba Sheikh AlMajlesy: He (Prophet (p)) said that because Imaan (faith) started from Mecca which is Touhama from the region of Yemen and so it was called: The Yamani Kaaba Sheikh Ali AlNumazi v.10 p.602 and Bihar AlAnwar v.22 p.1 Finally, there is a clear statement from the Ahlulbayt pbut about the necessity of submitting to their commands even if the location of the matter changes. It is not allowed to belie it as long as the matter that they pbuh reported about happened.  Abu Jafar and Abu Abdullah pbut said: “O Aba Hamza, if we spoke about a matter that it will come from here but then it came from there, Allah can do what he wants. And if we report to you today of a narration and then tomorrow we report something opposing it. Allah erases what he wants and confirms.” Bihar AlAnwar Vol.4 Page 119 The command of Ahlulbayt pbut is evident, that Bada (changes in Divine decree) can happen in the details, for example, the location of a certain matter. Therefore, nothing remains for this misconception, that is based on a hadith which is Ahad (single), weak in its chain according to them, and differs in its content (Matn), and finally which can be subject to Bada. Here is a Youtube video about this misconception!

Is Yamani from Yemen? Read More »

Is the claim before Al-Sufyani a lie?

The narration of the last Tawqee has often been used by the opponents of the call even though it has been refuted long ago by Ansar Al-Mahdi (p). It is the narration by the 12th Imam (p) to his fourth deputy, Ali Ibn Muhammad al-Samarri, about the beginning of major occultation and the statement that any claim before the appearance of Al-Sufyani will be a lie: “In the name of Allah, the all-Merciful, the especially-Merciful. O Ali Ibn Muhammad al-Samarri! May Allah increase the reward of your brothers concerning you (i.e. your demise)! Death will come to you within the next six days. So you complete your works and do not nominate any person after you. The sequence of special deputies will come to an end and the Major Occultation will commence with your demise. Now the reappearance will occur only with the permission of Allah, after a prolonged period and after the hearts of people are hardened. And such a period will emerge on my Shias when people will claim that they have met with me. Whoever makes such a claim before the advent of the Sufyani and the call from the sky is a liar, an impostor. And there is no strength nor power except from Allah, the High, the Great.” Al Ghaybah by Shaikh at-Tusi, p. 593 Response It’s Sanad (chain of narrators) is not credible according to the Shias. Refer to Al-Majlisi in Bihar Al-Anwar, Volume 35 Page 318, and Al-Kathimi in Bisharat Al-Islam Page 146.  They say that the narration of the Al-Samarri is “Khabar Wahid Mursal“. Khabar Al-Wahid is one which is narrated by people whose number does not reach that of the Mutawatir case, meaning their number is few, and therefore there is a possibility of doubt and falsehood. Mursal literally means ‘hurried’. Mursal is a hadith where the narrator narrated it without mentioning the chain of narrators. According to their own rules, even if it had Sahih Sanad (credible chain of narrators), it would not benefit the belief (Aqeeda) without being supported by that which would deliver certitude regarding its issuing. All of the scholars agree that when it comes to belief, doubt is not enough. Belief must be attained by certitude (Yaqeen) and knowledge ( Ilm). Khabar Al-Wahid, at the most, could provide doubt, but not knowledge (Ilm), as they declare. Its content (Matn) is allegorical, and a lot of the scholars have understood it with different understandings. It is not indicative of the matter being enclosed for everyone. Musawara deals with matters that indicate totality or partiality. A matter is deemed partial if the totality is not evident. For example, using ‘whoever’ in this hadith indicates partiality. If it was, ‘Everyone who claim…. shall be a slanderous liar’, it would have been a case of totality. Anything else, whether, ‘some’, ‘few’, ‘any’, ‘whoever’, etc., are considered as indicative towards partiality, and don’t include everyone. This narration is refuted by many narrations and events. For example, the narration of the Yamani, the narration of green island, and many other narrations about a special servant of 12th Imam (p) before his emergence. Some example of such narrations are: The narration of Green Island O Master, indeed Our scholars have narrated some traditions about the Companion of the Matter (PBUH), that he said when he was commanded to enter into the Major Occultation, “Whoever claims to have seen me during my Major Occultation is a liar.” In spite of that so many have seen him, even from among you?’ So, he said, ‘You have told the truth, but he (p) said that during that time because there was a large number of enemies from his family as well as from others from the tyrants of Bani Al-Abbas, so much so that the Shia used to prevent one another from speaking about or mentioning the Imam. As for the current time period, a lot of time has passed and the enemy has despaired. Our territories are out of their control and we are safe from their oppression and through the blessing of the Imam (p) none of the enemies can reach us.’ Al-Meerza Al-Noori in ‘Al-Najam Al-Thaqab, V.2, P. 172 Al-Sayeed Noor Allah Al-Tastary in ‘Mujalis Al-Mu’mineen, V. 1, P. 78 Al-Sheikh Ali Al-Hairi in ‘Al-Zam Al-Nasib, V. 2, P. 85 Al-Maqads Al-aradabeely in ‘Hadeqa Al-Shia, P. 728. The narration of Yamani Imam Al-Baqer pbuh said: “There is no banner more guided than the banner of the Yamani. It is the banner of guidance because he calls to your possessor. If the Yamani emerges he will forbid the selling of weapons to people and every Muslim. If the Yamani emerges go to him for his banner is the banner of guidance. It is forbidden for any Muslim to turn away from him. Whoever does that is from the people of hell because he calls to the truth and straight path.” Gaibat Al Numani p.264 The narration of special representative before the rise Imam Qaim (p) will go into occultation in some of these passes, and he pointed out with his hand to the direction of Zeetawa. Then he said: “When two days remain from his rising, one of his special servants would come to his particular companions and ask: ‘How many of you are there?’ He would reply: ‘We are forty people.’ Then he will ask: ‘What will you do if you see your Companion (p)’ They will reply: ‘By Allah, if he goes from here and takes refuge at any mountain, we would also be with him.’ Then he will come to them and say: ‘Point to ten of your leaders or the best of you,’ then they point to them for him, so he takes them and brings them to their Companion (p), and he shall promise them the coming night.” Ghaibah Al-Namani, page 187 The narration of successor of 12th Imam during the major occultation Imam Al-Sadiq pbuh said: The companion of the affair has two occultations. One of them

Is the claim before Al-Sufyani a lie? Read More »

Scroll to Top