Religious Delusion- Sunnis

Sunni Scholars and Evolution Part 2

This is part 2 of the response by Ahmed Alhasan to one of the Sunni Scholars about evolution. This excerpt is taken from the book Atheism Delusion. Ashqar ¹  continues: Response: Ashqar believes that present-day man, Homo sapiens, has evolved from the present-day ape, which isn’t the case. The truth of the matter is that humans and present-day great apes share a common ancestor. Due to his ignorance or misunderstanding of evolution, he demands that present-day apes evolve into humans because he imagines it happened in the past, whereas humans and modern apes diverged millions of years ago. This means that present-day great apes and humans have a common ancestor, but they split into two different lineages. That’s why it’s scientifically impossible for a present-day ape to evolve into a human, since apes took a different evolutionary path than humans millions of years ago. It’s also nearly impossible to imagine apes going backwards on the evolutionary path to the original point of divergence from humans, and then taking the same evolutionary path that humans have taken. As for the lineage from which chimpanzees split and humans evolved, the only remaining member is the present-day human—Homo sapiens, so no one can ask why all members of the human lineage didn’t evolve into humans. The truth is that all members of this lineage evolved into distinct species, one of them being the present-day human. As for the question of whether evolution continues today or not, the answer is yes, it still continues in nature, even though the evolution of most organisms isn’t something we can observe because our lives are short, and their life cycle is long. However, it is possible for us to observe evolution in some insects since they do have a short life cycle. Through observations of certain insect species in their natural habitat, we can see clear indications of evolution and dramatic changes in their traits. These are established facts that anyone can verify. Regarding his demand for a female to evolve, it is truly the most extreme form of ignorance, because evolution occurs within an entire species. One of the pillars of evolution is reproduction, or the transfer of genes to the next generation. For example, when a mutation that alters leg straightness occurs in a female, she passes it to her offspring, whether they are male or female. The same is true for a male. When a mutation occurs, he passes it to his offspring, whether male or female. These mutations are small and don’t remove an individual from its species, so a mate doesn’t need to have the same mutation for them to be able to reproduce. The individual can still breed with others of the same species who don’t have that mutation. If the mutation leads to a favored trait, it becomes firmly established through natural selection. Eventually, those individuals possessing this trait will entirely dominate the species. Furthermore, evolution does not occur without reproduction. So how could anyone imagine that males and females would evolve separately to the point of becoming two different species, so that  Ashqar would demand that the female evolve after the male? By God! It’s tragic that these people respond to the theory of evolution with such worthless and ignorant remarks! Ashqar’s third point clearly shows his extreme ignorance of evolution. The man barely understands a thing about the theory he set out to refute.As for his comparison of the senses, I don’t know why he finds it so strange that certain sensory mechanisms are more advanced in animals than humans. This is beyond dispute, and everyone agrees on it. For example, humans lack the sonar of bats, as well as the sight possessed by hawks. Does he disagree with these scientific, empirical, and anatomical facts?! Ashqar: Response: The theory of evolution is a scientific theory. It is currently the only one recognized by all well-established universities and research centers around the world to explain life on Earth. European and American universities are still teaching the theory of evolution, and neither they nor any other academically respected university has ever stopped doing so. Therefore, I don’t know where Ashqar got this fabrication:  As a matter of fact, the opposite is true. Advancements in genetics have proven the theory of evolution with irrefutable scientific evidence, and it can’t even be the topic of any substantial opposing argument. Two examples of genetic evidence are retroviruses and the fusion of Chromosome 2 in humans. ¹ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Umar_Sulaiman_Al-Ashqar Part 1: Click here The excerpt is taken from Atheism Delusion by Ahmed Alhasan احمد الحسن Click here to read similar glaring delusions of men of religion.

Sunni Scholars and Evolution Part 2 Read More »

Sunni Scholars and Evolution Part 1

This is part 1 of the response by Ahmed Alhasan to one of the Sunni scholars about evolution. This excerpt is taken from the book Atheism Delusion. It is well-known that Al-Azhar University, which represents the Ashari and Maturidi Sunni ideologies, rejects the theory of evolution. Here are some statements from an Al-Azhar graduate who claims to refute evolution: Dr. Umar Sulaiman Ashqar ¹ , in his book Al-Aqeeda fi Allah [Belief in God], begins by explaining his understanding of Darwin’s theory, or the theory of evolution : Response: Abiogenesis is a theory that explains the origin of the first replicators and how they emerged on Earth. It doesn’t have anything to do with the traits of organisms or the law of natural selection. It deals with how the first protein or the first self-replicator, representing the simplest origin of life, came into existence. In regards to organisms evolving and carrying new traits throughout evolution, that’s not the theory of abiogenesis but rather, the process of evolution, while the appearance of a new organism expressing enough traits to separate it from its relatives during the evolutionary process is called speciation or diversification.Wonders never cease with people like Ashqar, who delve into a science they know nothing about. He’s not even capable of distinguishing the theory of abiogenesis from the theory of evolution, or development from speciation, yet he says the theory of evolution is false, and sets out to refute it! Ashqar later says: Response: Here again, he shows his misunderstanding of the theory of evolution when he says: This is incorrect. According to the theory of evolution, the eye didn’t come into existence suddenly. At first, there were cells that sensed the organism’s environment, which then specialized in sensing light. After that, they multiplied and arched, followed by shrinking of the aperture through which light enters, and then the lens formed. This is how the modern eye evolved—through minute cumulative steps taking place over millions of years and many time periods. As for Ashqar’s reference to circumcision, it shows that he understands nothing about the theory of evolution. What does circumcision or tradition have to do with the theory of evolution? Evolution occurs when an organism has a favored genetic trait, and circumcision is not a genetic trait. Rather, it is a surgical procedure that certain groups habitually perform. Customs and surgical procedures can’t be inherited. It is genetic traits that are inherited, and can therefore have a role in evolution. By God, how strange that a person who understands nothing about the theory of evolution writes a book to refute it, and considers it a scientific response! There is no might or power except in God. ¹ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Umar_Sulaiman_Al-Ashqar Part 2: Click here The excerpt is taken from Atheism Delusion by Ahmed Alhasan احمد الحسن Click here to read similar glaring delusions of men of religion.

Sunni Scholars and Evolution Part 1 Read More »

Scroll to Top