Religious Delusion- Shias

Sayyid Ali Sistani and Evolution Part 2

This is part 2 of the response by Ahmed Alhasan to Sayyid Ali Sistani about evolution. This excerpt is taken from the book Atheism Delusion. From Sistani’s ¹ Center of Belief Researches website: Quoting from Thimar Al-Afkar [The Fruits of Thoughts] by Sheikh Ali Al-Korani Al-Amili ² , 354-357: Response: In summary, what they quote from Korani’s book is that entropy obligates complex systems to move toward breaking down, and that the universe as a whole is moving toward breaking down, as is Earth and all that it encompasses. According to them, there is relapse and regression, not evolution. In fact, this argument was first raised by Dr. Henry Morris, who said the second law of thermodynamics states that everything tends toward disorder, making the process of evolution impossible (Morris 1974). The fundamentalist Christians in the United States and Europe pounced on this argument to respond to the theory of evolution. This argument was rehashed by some Arabs after it was translated, and Korani’s friend relayed it. If only he would have just left it as it was instead of adding words to it that demonstrate complete ignorance. Consequently, Korani also pounced on it and put it in his book. Then the ideological website belonging to Sistani took it from Korani, and adopted it as fact and evidence that refutes the theory of evolution. Overall, it is a trivial argument, and both scientifically incomplete and incorrect. Even though it will be shown later that what observation has led to, and what is now widely accepted by science, is that the universe is flat, open, and expanding at an accelerating rate. Nevertheless, and descending to their level, let’s assume that the physical universe is a closed system to which the second law of thermodynamics applies—since entropy doesn’t decrease within a closed system—and that entropy is increasing in the universe. This doesn’t mean that every part of the universe moves in this direction, or said another way, moves toward increased entropy. It is possible that parts of the universe (which we’ve assumed to be a closed system), such as the Earth, are moving toward more order (at times), as long as other parts are balancing them with increased entropy. What matters is that the system as a whole doesn’t violate the second law of thermodynamics. This shows that their argument is built on a fragile foundation and a superficial understanding of the second law of thermodynamics. Moreover, the earth itself is not a closed system. There is actually more than one energy exchange system existing within it, and also, there are systems that exchange with it. For example, the sun gives heat and light to the earth, and parts of the earth experience night and day successively, dividing it into several systems. This causes the earth to experience a variable and continuous process of heat exchange since there are a number of systems rather than just one. In addition to this, because the earth’s core is hot and consists of magma, there are unorganized processes of energy exchange occurring between the core, crust, and atmosphere of the Earth. The Earth’s surrounding space is a system as well, and heat exchange occurs between this space and the Earth. The moon’s gravity also affects the Earth, and its effect is even changing over time as it continuously recedes from the Earth. Therefore, based on the Earth’s state as described above, the law of thermodynamics for two systems would be: “the total entropy of two systems doesn’t decrease when heat exchange occurs between the two”. This means that increasing order on the Earth is possible because it exchanges energy with the surrounding universe. Similarly, increasing order in some parts of the Earth is also possible, because several systems are exchanging energy with each other. What matters is that the total entropy of both systems, not just one of them, doesn’t decrease. The Earth itself is neither a closed system nor a single system. Rather, it is multiple systems. It could be that entropy increases in one place on the Earth while decreasing in another, as it is possible for deterioration of life, demolition, earthquakes, and floods to occur in one place on Earth, while at the same time construction, growth and flourishing of life occur in another. This is something we witness every day, and it doesn’t break the second law of thermodynamics. Furthermore, it is a foregone conclusion that the universe has not moved toward collapse either in the past or present. It has been scientifically proven, by observing a type of supernova, cosmic background radiation and the Doppler effect, that the universe is flat and expanding at an accelerating rate, and that it will continue to do so for a long time. We will address this issue when we discuss dark energy. I believe that my clarification of entropy and the second law of thermodynamics is sufficient to rebut the above mentioned naive argument. But to simplify it even more, let’s put entropy aside and move on to the conclusion that they draw and rely on, which is their claim that the universe has moved and still is moving toward disintegration, decay, and dissolution. Their conclusion is incorrect. The situation is the complete opposite according to observations and precise astronomical monitoring, the results of which have proven that, alongside the Doppler effect, cosmic background radiation, and observation of supernovas, that galaxies are moving away from each other at an accelerating rate. The material universe we live in has been and still is expanding, growing, and proliferating. Even the galaxy we live in still contains clouds of gas and dust where the formation and birth of new stars take place, and this will continue for a long time. This scientific fact, proven beyond doubt, is enough to refute what Korani has stated in his book. In addition to that, the universe didn’t begin as a compound-complex universe according to the Standard Model or Big Bang theory, which is proven by scientific evidence such

Sayyid Ali Sistani and Evolution Part 2 Read More »

Sayyid Ali Sistani and Evolution Part 1

This is part 1 of the response by Ahmed Alhasan to Sayyid Ali Sistani about evolution. This excerpt is taken from the book Atheism Delusion. I found the following statement on Sayyid Ali Sistani’s¹ ideological website². If it doesn’t represent his opinion, he can say so and give his own. Otherwise, the opinions are his, and he is bound by this response. From Sistani’s Center of Belief Researches website: Response: What is mentioned above represents Sistani’s opinion and response regarding the theory of evolution, or at the very least, a response that Sistani is satisfied with. There is no problem with making its value and quality clear. He states here that the theory of evolution has been proven to be scientifically false. I truly don’t know where this has ever happened! Perhaps only in their delusions. In fact, the theory of evolution has been proven to be scientifically correct, especially with the advent of genetics and the advancements in this field. It is currently being taught in the schools of developed countries and in all well-established universities worldwide. In addition to that, many vaccines and medical treatments are being produced and developed based on this theory. He then presented his scientific evidence, essentially just superficial words that reveal the author’s ignorance of the theory of evolution. This theory does not state that a mutation will transform one animal or species into another. It also doesn’t state that the emergence of complex organs occurs suddenly (for example, that an animal without eyes will suddenly have eyes, and so on), which would create a problem with mathematical probabilities that would stand in the way of the theory of evolution. Actually, evolution occurs through a tremendous number of very slow steps. Since they are cumulative, the probability associated with each evolutionary step occurring individually isn’t mathematically problematic. Moreover, the probability of each step following the previous one is very high due to the presence of variation, reproduction, and natural selection at every stage. If all three of these factors are present, evolution will definitely be present as well. This is a scientific fact denied only by people who don’t understand variation, reproduction and selection, and their implications. I advise Sayyid Sistani and the Center of Belief Researches to read what evolution scientists have written, so they can understand the theory of evolution before issuing such statements that only demonstrate their ignorance of the theory and its mechanisms. From Sistani’s Center of Belief Researches website: Response: Their use of ambiguous Quranic verses to refute a proven scientific theory has no scientific value for biologists, and it doesn’t have any religious value either. None of these verses oppose the theory of evolution conclusively so that someone can say, for example, that religion and evolution can’t both be true at the same time. Their statement that the creation of man began with clay, and their use of relevant Quranic verses, can be responded to by simply saying that these verses pertain to the creation of the soul. The clay creation occurred in heaven, as stated by the same Quranic verses that mention the story of creation. This has been mentioned in narrations as well. Heaven is a world of souls, not a physical, material world like this one as we’ll clarify later, God willing. Another response is that the creation of man began when God created the first “gene map”, or the first replicable protein, since this protein was created from the chemical substances available on this Earth, in its soil, or from clay particles. It is true that in this way, God has created man from mud, soil, clay, and earth, because man is the goal intended to be reached from creation.  So the verses about the creation of Adam from clay and soil can be understood to be in complete agreement with evolution. At the same time, we find other verses that clearly support the theory of evolution. The Almighty said,{While He has created you in stages ✶ Do you not see how God has created the seven heavens in layers ✶ And made the moon a light therein and the sun a burning lamp? And God has caused you to grow from the earth as a plant} Quran Chapter “Noah” 71:14-17. The verses are clear: {He has created you in stages . . . And God has caused you to grow from the earth as a plant}. A detailed explanation of these verses will come later. ¹ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ali_al-Sistani ² https://www.sistani.org/ Part 2: Click here The excerpt is taken from Atheism Delusion by Ahmed Alhasan احمد الحسن Click here to read similar glaring delusions of men of religion.

Sayyid Ali Sistani and Evolution Part 1 Read More »

Sheikh Jafar Sobhani and Evolution

This is a response by Ahmed Alhasan to some of the Shia scholars about evolution. This excerpt is taken from the book Atheism Delusion. In his book Al-Manahij al-Tafsiriyya [Interpretive Methods], Sheikh Jafar Sobhani¹ says It seems that Sheikh Jafar, may God guide him to the truth, loves to jest. He wrote, “Those are my fathers, so show me their likes,” without recognizing that those “fathers”, as Sheikh Jafar called them, are physical ancestors that he undoubtedly shares with the biologist Charles Darwin. If they are proven to be Darwin’s ancestors, then they are Jafar Sobhani’s ancestors, as well as the ancestors of every other human being on Earth. On the other hand, if they are not proven to be Sheikh Jafar Sobhani’s ancestors, or “fathers”, then they are definitely not Darwin’s either. Proving or disproving this is a matter of science that I doubt Sheikh Jafar and his fellow Shia authorities (marja) capable of delving into and discussing scientifically. This is especially true considering that his statement about Darwin’s theory is riddled with errors. He said that Charles Darwin published his book The Transformation of Species in 1908, but Darwin actually died in 1882 and never wrote a book titled The Transformation of Species. He did, however, write The Origin of Species, which was published in 1859, but it didn’t deal with the origin of man. He addressed the origin of man and his relationship to the great apes in another book, The Descent of Man and Selection in Relation to Sex. I truly don’t know what to say. It’s better that I leave it to the reader to comment. ¹ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ja%27far_Sobhani The excerpt is taken from Atheism Delusion by Ahmed Alhasan احمد الحسن Click here to read similar glaring delusions of men of religion.

Sheikh Jafar Sobhani and Evolution Read More »

Scroll to Top